This blog is hosted on Ideas on EuropeIdeas on Europe Avatar

Latest

Lending a helping hand or finger-pointing at the migrants and refugees in Covid-19 triggered ‘open moments’

Covid-19 (BBC)

My original plan was to write about Polish Presidential elections today, expected to take place in May 2020, despite the calls for its cancellation after the outbreak of the pandemic: Covid-19. The acceleration of the spread of coronavirus, however, have succeeded in drifting my attention to the refugees and migrants.  Particularly their survival in the light of the strict measures adopted by the EU and the MSs in the fight against the pandemic. The limitations brought to air travel and cross-border movements are particularly concerning as far as the migrants and refugees are concerned. 

What the ordinary people of the Western World are experiencing during this era of Covid-19 is distinct and onerous; a routine of social distancing and self-isolation are alien to our free, social and swank nature. I do not want to underplay the hardship we are all facing, but the vast majority of us have a ‘home to stay in’ and no one could deny that we have also been practising our’ stockpiling’ skills. However over-stretched, there are fantastic National Health systems, operating with the most qualified doctors, across the EU MSs, who would take care of us when we are in need. Also, let us not forget about our democratically elected political leaders who are determined to take us of this predicament. 

(Picture: Rob Timmerman/AFP/Getty)

While this is where we are, I cannot avoid but think about migrants and refugee who cannot self-isolate because they have to share tents with others, be that a family member or a relative, and they cannot socially distance since the camps are overcrowded and each tent accommodate more people than it should. For instance, in Greek island of Lesbos, where the Moria camp operates, designed initially to shelter 3,000 people temporarily, it is now the cramped home of more than 20,000. Similarly, the Vial camp on Chios is one of the smaller camps and holds more than 6,000 people in a space meant for 1,000. As we repeatedly hear from experts, personal hygiene is crucial in protection against Covid-19, can spare a minute to think about what it means to share 30 toilets between 6000 people and one shower for every 200 people at the Vial camp. Thus expecting to see a fully-fledged hospital with ventilators at these camps is unrealistic by any stretch of the imagination.

I agree with Filippo Grandi, UN High Commissioner for Refugees, who said that measures taken by the countries should not result in the closure of avenues to asylum, or of forcing people to return to situations of danger. However, the choices made by the EU MSs and others are already and unintentionally putting these people’ future in limbo. Additionally, I agree with Grandi who proposed if there are health risks; screening arrangements can be put in place, together with testing, quarantine and other measures. These will enable authorities to manage the arrival of asylum seekers and refugees safely while respecting international refugee protection standards designed to save lives.

As far as I know, there is not a reported case of Covid-19 from existing camps, but it is unthinkable that coronavirus skips the refugee camps. When it begins to spread, the calamity this may entail is the concern; plus whether anyone would volunteer to lend a helping hand, except for the NGOs who are already doing their utmost, is also the fear. Furthermore, my deliberate question concerns what is expecting the refugees and migrants during this chaotic epoch. Particularly after Viktor Orban, the Hungarian PM, the EU’s most anti-migrant Illiberal-Eurosceptic political leader, finger-pointed at the migrants and refugees for a ‘certain link’ between the spread of the virus and them.

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban (photo by Tamas Kovacs)

Orban’s choice of words is a product of his blame-evading style; thus, it is not surprising that he is linking refugees or migrants to the fast-spreading nature of Covid-19. However, what is distressing is having politicians of this calibre in charge of the management of the pandemic-driven crisis in a significantly relaxed political setting, be that domestic political setting(Hungary) or the EU. 

If we recognise our current state being, that is triggered by Covid-19, as a critical juncture that has ultimately put on hold every part of our modern life.  Peter Gourevitch’s (1986) description of critical junctures as “open moments when system creating choices are made” where the rules of decision making are relaxed can help to ask the following questions: what factors may affect their choices during these open times? Whether politicians for their interests could exploit these open moments? What system creating choices shall we expect to see? Should we worry about our politicians operating in a political setting where the rule of decision making is relaxed? Is this a time for politicians to make life-changing decisions for the migrants and refugee? Is this an opportunity for migrants and refugees or a misfortune?

In the coming days and weeks, I will follow on Covid-19 situation with particular attention to the migrants and refugees, as well on political leaders’ choices and decisions in these open and relaxed moments, and the consequences this may have for both those vulnerable and the existing democratic political settings we behold. As I was writing this blog, the Hungarian was discussing introducing a new set of rules that would support the state of emergency in Hungary, which might also allow Orban to rule by decree for an unlimited time. We do not yet know what this means for the illiberal Hungarian democracy.

I will post again.

COMMENT

Recent Articles

When one door closes, another opens…

Published on by | Comments Off on When one door closes, another opens…

On Monday, 10th Feb, I attended the UCL’s European Careers Event 2020. It was organised for graduates, particularly of the UCL and others. Since I am not an institutionalised academic, I do not have a piece of first-hand knowledge to what talks are taking places in the European Studies Departments across the country about the […]

Awkward partner is now out, the Rule of Law debate is here to stay

Published on by | Comments Off on Awkward partner is now out, the Rule of Law debate is here to stay

Just as the UK government is making its final preparations for the fast-approaching Brexit Day, I am just wondering who is looking forward to the Transition Period, and all the drama that might follow it. My super cautious and alarmed older brother, who is a British Passport holder, has already made his final visit to […]

Political power feels GOOD—Orban and Kaczynski will not risk losing the GRIP.

Published on by | Comments Off on Political power feels GOOD—Orban and Kaczynski will not risk losing the GRIP.

When Viktor Orban, the Hungarian Prime Minister and the leader of Fidesz (Hungarian Civic Alliance), lost the General Elections in 2002, his advisor of the time Jozsef Debreczeni said Orban had drawn one conclusion from this election result: “This democracy thing, where power can slip so quickly from you, was no good.” Despite gaining 13 […]

‘Trick Or Treat?’ Trick: Let Us Not Forget That Boris Johnson Attempted To Prorogue the UK Parliament!

Published on by | Comments Off on ‘Trick Or Treat?’ Trick: Let Us Not Forget That Boris Johnson Attempted To Prorogue the UK Parliament!

Phew, what a couple of months. But wait, the political drama is to continue at home in Brexitland in the coming months. As I was writing this blog, the British MPs were debating the UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s deal with the EU on the UK’s exit from the European Union. However, by the time […]

The EU’s Troublemakers and the Question of Immigration in The Context Of An Online E-mail Interview Experience

Published on by | Comments Off on The EU’s Troublemakers and the Question of Immigration in The Context Of An Online E-mail Interview Experience

What This Blog Is Not About The refugee crisis and the EU’s mismanagement of it have been what I have following up on since 2\015. Particularly the EU-Turkey migration deal (March 2016) and Poland and Hungary’s position on the EU’s refugee quota system (2017) have been under my radar. Now that the Turkish side announced to […]

New Beginnings in Turkey post-Istanbul Mayoral elections or Not

Published on by | Comments Off on New Beginnings in Turkey post-Istanbul Mayoral elections or Not

I have not commented on Turkish politics for a while now for I thought not much is changing in Turkey since 2013, except there has been a constant and continuous democratic backsliding and the reign of the Justice and Development Party for almost two decades. What today’s Istanbul Mayoral election result represents is a critical […]

#EP2019—Insights from Poland: the PiS vs the Coalition Europe (IV)

Published on by | Comments Off on #EP2019—Insights from Poland: the PiS vs the Coalition Europe (IV)

As Poland is heading for a General Elections in the Autumn this year, both the governing and opposition political parties are treating the European Parliament election, that is only weeks away, as secondary to the General Elections. Yes, both sides are running a campaign to mobilise their activists and supporters to increase their share of […]

#EP2019–Why May 2019 EP elections are most critical and what are the main issues? (III)

Published on by | Comments Off on #EP2019–Why May 2019 EP elections are most critical and what are the main issues? (III)

The first European Parliament elections took place in 1979 when the European Union then was known as the European Community, consisted of only nine member states. The United Kingdom was one of the nine members; Hungary and Poland’s membership of the EU was unimaginable at the time. While the EP was recognised as a ‘talking […]

#EP2019—Brexit Delay and the Suspension of Fidesz (II)

Published on by | Comments Off on #EP2019—Brexit Delay and the Suspension of Fidesz (II)

Nine weeks away from the European Parliament elections, Brexit and the suspension of Fidesz from the European People’ Party has been worthwhile developments to pay attention to in the context of the EP elections campaigns. The evening of the 20th of March and the following day have been critical moments for both the British and […]

UACES and Ideas on Europe do not take responsibility for opinions expressed in articles on blogs hosted on Ideas on Europe. All opinions are those of the contributing authors.